Press "Enter" to skip to content

Why Igby Decreases Is a Perfect Spiritual Movie Adjustment of The Catcher in the Rye

The literary classic, The Catcher in the Rye is not likely to get a movie adjustment. That being stated, Igby Decreases is a fantastic alternative.

J.D. Salinger’s 1951 unique The Catcher in the Rye is one that lots of high school trainees recognize with; it is a preferred among English instructors. And it’s not difficult to see why it would have such a time-enduring appeal. It’s a coming-of-age story (albeit a male-centric one) that most teenagers going through a defiant, angsty, or otherwise complicated stage in their lives can connect to. Even if one has yet to go through this stage or is a couple of years past it, associating with the primary character of Holden Caulfield is a basic job. Holden is hypocritical, as most people often are; he is afraid, as most people often are; and he is constantly discovering, as everybody constantly are.


While the unique definitely has its fans, it likewise has its critics. Some mention Holden as being too unlikable. Others believe that The Catcher in the Rye requires to stop being declared as the gold requirement of coming-of-age stories. And while the realities to those 2 ideas are completely subjective, they are well-founded reviews, as legitimate as any appreciation.

While Salinger was still alive, he appeared to be open up to making a movie adjustment of his book. Nevertheless, he notoriously turned down lots of deals made, consisting of Stephen Spielberg’s. Although with his death, an adjustment is not likely, there is a movie out there that shares lots of resemblances with The Catcher in the Rye and can be seen through similar lens as the book.

Here’s why Igby Decreases is a best spiritual movie adjustment of The Catcher in the Rye.

Igby & Holden: Comparable Battles

Igby Slocumb (Kieran Culkin) and Holden Caulfield’s resemblances start with their relationship to school. Really early on in both The Catcher in the Rye and Igby Decreases, it is well developed that they tend to get tossed out of or stop a lot of the universities they get sent out to. In Igby’s case, this likewise consists of a military college. The Caulfields are likewise recommended to have good wealth, having the ability to send their child to these schools, while the Slocumbs are straight-out shown to have an enormous fortune. Both Igby and Holden’s monetary status enters play as significant barriers in their particular journeys. The 2 of them have trouble discovering shelter each night; while Igby’s living scenario is more protected, it’s still vulnerable.

Surpassing the more circumstantial resemblances, both young boys battle with their relationships, familial and romantic. Holden is irregular, going from wishing to be with the ladies in his life to talking to them condescendingly. Igby is more effective than Holden, however his absence of instructions expenses him 2 romantic pursuits in the movie.

In regards to household, Holden has a much better relationship with his moms and dads and brother or sisters, understanding extremely well that it’s his fault for his present scenarios and doting on his little sis. Nevertheless, Igby actively resents his mom and has an exhausting relationship with his older sibling. Both of which he sees (with excellent factor) as aggressive and vicious people. While these might highlight distinctions, each of their house lives results in their journeys. Holden does not wish to face his household for worry of what they’ll state to him, while Igby wishes to escape his household due to the fact that of his distaste for them.

Igby & Holden: Ending on a High Note

For all the ethically doubtful things that Holden and Igby do throughout their character arcs, in the end, they take the appropriate actions to much better themselves. At the end of The Catcher in the Rye, Holden goes to deal with his older sibling and remains in a psychological healthcare facility. While at the end of Igby Decreases, Igby leaves for Los Angeles to get a break from his household and the toxic environment they have actually cultivated.

These moments are necessary due to the fact that both characters invest a big bulk of their time failing a down spiral. The choices that they make just serve to dig themselves into much deeper holes. For Holden, it’s his pursuit of females (which generally ends in failure), and for Igby, it’s his substance abuse. Without this minute of securing their own psychological health, their character arcs would be incongruent and insufficient. And by doing so, they end on a high note, a recommendation for anybody going through a comparable journey that it improves.

While Igby Decreases and The Catcher in the Rye do not mirror each other completely, the resemblances suffice that a fan of one would likewise likely be a fan of the other. Igby Decreases positions a greater focus on funny and being sardonic, while The Catcher in the Rye informs a more succinct story of the frame of mind of a teenage young boy. And while The Catcher in the Rye most likely will not get a faithful movie adjustment anytime quickly, Igby Decreases must suffice to satisfy fans till that time comes.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.